Harbor & Pine Wealth
Equity tax report · Prepared by Jordan Ellis, CPA, Harbor & Pine Wealth
Sample: Dana & Lee Park, IPO year
Tax year 2026 · Prepared Nov 19, 2026
New York
Prepared for Dana & Lee Park
Base case at the share price entered. The range below shows how the answer moves with price.
Cash income
$730,000
Salary, equity and sales
Total tax
$255,669
35.0% of cash income
Cash after tax
$474,331
After every tax
Still to set aside
$33,766
Plus $3,177 refund due
Low / base / high share price
Same scenario, run three times through the engine. Only the share price changes.
| Share price | Low$30.00 | Base$50.00 | High$70.00 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total tax | $206,833 | $255,669 | $304,940 |
| Take-home after tax | $375,167 | $426,331 | $477,060 |
| Still to set aside | $22,053 | $33,766 | $47,961 |
| AMT owed | $0 | $0 | $0 |
Federal (IRS)
Tax for the year$183,578
Withheld from pay$149,812
Still owed$33,766
New York
Tax for the year$71,205
Withheld from pay$74,382
Refund expected$3,177
Quarterly estimated payments
Q1 · due Apr 15, 2026$0
Q2 · due Jun 15, 2026$0
Q3 · due Sep 15, 2026$68
Q4 · due Jan 15, 2027$18,356
Penalty if paid in April instead$320
For the tax preparer
W-2, Box 1Equity pay included in your wages (RSUs, NSOs, ESPP)$250,000
Form 8949 / Sch. DNet short-term gain$20,000
Form 8949 / Sch. DNet long-term gain$60,000
Form 8960Net investment income tax$3,040
Form 8959Additional Medicare tax$3,600
Form 2210Estimated underpayment penalty$320
Advisor analysis
We start with salary alone, then add each equity event one at a time and record how much more tax it adds. The rows add up to the year's full tax. Example: with a $200,000 salary, $100,000 of RSUs vesting adds about $31,400 of federal income tax and $2,350 of Medicare, because those dollars land in the 32% to 35% brackets. Events further down the list pay the higher rates that earlier ones pushed income into, so order matters.
| Event | Income added | Fed. income tax | Payroll | NIIT | State & local | Total tax |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Salary and other regular income | $352,000 | $55,068 | $27,889 | — | $34,507 | $118,351 |
| RSU vesting | $250,000 | $73,901 | $5,875 | — | $28,117 | $107,892 |
| Share sale 1 (short-term, 1000 shares) | $20,000 | $7,000 | — | $760 | $2,145 | $9,905 |
| Share sale 2 (long-term, 2000 shares) | $60,000 | $10,805 | — | $2,280 | $6,436 | $19,521 |
| Total | $682,000 | $146,774 | $33,764 | $3,040 | $71,205 | $255,669 |
- Projection share price: $50.00. Every future vest, exercise and sale uses this one price; no growth rate is assumed.
- Years after 2026 keep salary and other regular income unchanged and use the 2026 tax brackets, AMT exemption and thresholds. Real future brackets will be adjusted for inflation.
- Unvested RSUs vesting in 2026 are assumed to be in the scenario's RSU entry already; only vests in later years are added.
- Starting AMT credit: $8,000.00, from the client's prior-year Form 8801. Unused credit and capital losses carry forward year to year.
- Event attribution adds each event on top of salary in this order: RSUs, NSOs, ISOs, early exercise, ESPP, common stock, each sale, then other brokerage sales. Later events pay the higher rates earlier ones pushed income into.
Income
Everything that counts as income this year. "Taxed like salary" means it is added to pay and taxed at the same rates. Example: a $200,000 salary plus $50,000 of RSUs vesting means $250,000 of income before deductions.
Tax rules behind this: IRC Section 61; Section 83(a); Section 62; Section 1222
Where the tax comes from
Income is added one piece at a time (salary, then RSUs, NSOs, ISOs, then stock sales) and we record how much the tax goes up at each step. Later pieces land in higher brackets, so they show a higher rate. Example: a $150,000 salary averages about 20%, while $100,000 of RSUs added on top lands in the 32% and 35% brackets.
Tax rules behind this: IRC Section 1
Federal tax
A deduction comes off first, then the rest is taxed in brackets. The marginal rate is the rate on the last dollar, not on all income. Example: with a 24% marginal rate, $1,000 more of RSUs adds about $240 of federal income tax.
Tax rules behind this: IRC Section 63; Section 1; Section 55; Section 1411; Section 3101; Form 8960
Capital gains effective rate
Gains are taxed on their own schedule, separate from salary, so their rate is different. This is tax on gains ÷ gains, including the 3.8% NIIT. Example: $100,000 of long-term gains taxed $23,800 federally is a 23.8% federal rate.
Tax rules behind this: IRC Section 1(h); Section 1411; Form 8960
State tax — New York
The state works out its own tax on the same income, with its own brackets and deductions, separately from the IRS. Example: California taxes long-term gains at the same rates as salary, while Washington taxes only large long-term gains.
Tax rules behind this: New York tax agency; N.Y. Tax Law Section 601 (rates); N.Y. Tax Law Section 614 (standard deduction); NY Department of Taxation and Finance (administers NYC tax); N.Y. Tax Law Section 1304 (NYC rates)
Total tax, line by line
Every tax counted in your total, each on its own line, so you can see they add up. Payroll lines (Social Security, Medicare and any state disability or paid-leave contribution) are taken from each paycheck. Example: $100,000 federal income tax + $20,000 federal payroll + $30,000 state income tax + $4,000 state disability insurance = $154,000 total tax.
Withholding already taken
Everything already sent to the IRS and the state before filing: tax from paychecks, tax held back from RSUs and options, Social Security and Medicare, and any payments made directly. The balance is the tax minus all of that. Example: $60,000 of federal tax with $45,000 withheld leaves a $15,000 balance still owed.
Tax rules behind this: IRC Section 3402; Treas. Reg. Section 31.3402(g)-1; Section 31; Form W-4
Effective total rate
All tax for the year divided by the cash income that actually reached you. Paper gains on shares you still hold are left out, because no money arrived to pay from. Example: $90,000 of total tax on $300,000 of cash income is a 30% rate.
Where the IRS balance comes from
Each agency's tax is split into salary, stock compensation and share sales. For each, the tax it adds is compared with what was withheld or paid for it. Example: RSUs added $40,000 of federal tax but only $22,000 was withheld, so that piece is short $18,000.
Tax rules behind this: IRC Section 6654; Form 2210
Why there's a shortfall
- Your employer withheld about 22% federal tax on $250,000 of equity pay. Employers are allowed to use that flat rate, but this income is taxed in your 35% bracket, so every dollar came up short by the difference.
- Nothing is withheld when you sell stock. Your sales added $29,426 of tax, and none of it has been paid yet.
Why there's an overpayment
- The tax taken from your paychecks was more than the tax on your salary. Paycheck withholding assumes you earn the same amount all year and take no extra deductions, so it often takes a little too much.
Where the New York balance comes from
Each agency's tax is split into salary, stock compensation and share sales. For each, the tax it adds is compared with what was withheld or paid for it. Example: RSUs added $40,000 of federal tax but only $22,000 was withheld, so that piece is short $18,000.
Tax rules behind this: New York tax agency
Tax tables used
- Federal 2026 · published · updated Oct 28, 2026 · Verified Sept 2026 against IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (brackets, standard deduction, AMT, LTCG thresholds), SSA 2026 wage base ($184,500), IRS Q4 2026 underpayment rate (7%), and OBBBA (SALT, QSBS, AMT phaseout).
- New York 2026 · published · updated Oct 28, 2026 · Verified Sept 2026 against NYS DTF 2026 schedules (FY2026 budget lowered the first five rates by 0.1 point). Tax-benefit recapture for high incomes is modeled per Tax Law 601(d) and IT-201 tax computation worksheets.
Assumptions
- Tax year 2026, filing status Married filing jointly.
- Resident of New York for the full year unless a former state is entered.
- Employer withholding on equity pay uses the federal supplemental rates (22%, then 37% above $1M) unless a different rate was entered.
- Only the income, deductions and payments entered are counted. Tax credits and state itemized deductions are not modeled.
- Share price range: low $30.00, base $50.00, high $70.00. Every grant and sale price in the scenario moves by the same percentage; share counts and dates stay fixed.
Rules applied
- RSU settlement is ordinary wage incomeIRC Section 83(a); IRS Pub 525
- Supplemental withholding is a flat 22%, then 37% above $1MIRS Pub 15, Section 7
- Social Security stops at the wage base; Medicare doesn'tIRC Section 3101; Section 3102(f)
- NSO exercise creates ordinary income equal to the spreadIRC Section 83; Treas. Reg. Section 1.83-7
- ISO exercise is an AMT preference, not regular incomeIRC Section 421, Section 422, Section 56(b)(3)
- A disqualifying ISO sale turns the spread into ordinary incomeIRC Section 421(b); Section 422(c)(2)
- Only $100,000 of ISOs can first vest each yearIRC Section 422(d)
- AMT uses its own exemption, phaseout, and two ratesIRC Section 55
- AMT from ISOs becomes a credit laterIRC Section 53; Form 8801
- An 83(b) election taxes unvested shares when boughtIRC Section 83(b); Treas. Reg. Section 1.83-2
- ESPP gains depend on how long you holdIRC Section 423; Treas. Reg. Section 1.423-2
- Capital gains are netted short-term first, then long-term, then against each otherIRC Section 1211, Section 1212, Section 1222
- Long-term gains stack on top of ordinary incomeIRC Section 1(h)
- Net investment income tax applies to gains, not wagesIRC Section 1411
- QSBS can exclude most or all of the gainIRC Section 1202
- Acquisition cash is taxed now; stock may waitIRC Section 354, Section 356, Section 368
- State tax on equity follows workday sourcingCal. Rev. & Tax. Code Section 17951; FTB Pub 1100 (nonresidents and part-year residents); N.Y. Tax Law Section 631
- City income taxes stack on state taxN.Y. Tax Law Section 1304 (NYC rates)
- Safe harbor avoids the underpayment penaltyIRC Section 6654(d); IRS Pub 505
- The underpayment penalty is interest on each late installmentIRC Section 6621, Section 6654
Prepared by Harbor & Pine Wealth for planning discussion only. Not tax advice or a tax return. Powered by VestMath.
